Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Costa Concordia

Let me take a break from the fun and make some observations about the recent cruise ship disaster.
The first I heard of the Costa Concordia disaster, my heart filled with dread.  You develop a sense of security when you live on a ship, at least when it comes to sinking.  I honestly forget that we are sailing over the ocean - I just see it as a small city that I am living in.  Sure, it rocks around but you get used to it very quickly.  Passenger drills and crew drills become monotonous pains in the ass instead of a true training exercise.
Maybe I am in the minority of cruise ship crews, but I personally do not feel as though I would know what to do in an emergency, nor have I felt the need to find out (until now).  There are two major issues I can see clearly when it comes to safety: lack of training and too much pressure on making the guests comfortable.  
You learn about the emergency procedures the first day you get on the ship and its such a whirlwind of a day already that most of the information passed through one ear and out the other.  I was more focused on the basics of life - where I was sleeping, where I was eating, where I was working...  Since then, our safety and emergency training has consisted of “Stand here... make sure you put 20 passengers in that row... now stand there... move here... walk over there...”  There is no meaning behind it anymore.  We stand where we are told and we move where they tell us to move.
Each crew member is to have a specific job in an emergency situation.  On our cruise ship, everyone is issued an “Emergency Number” which helps to determine which muster station to go to, which life boat to run to, and (ideally) what to do in between.  The problem is that there are too many crew members to train individually so your predecessor has to tell you what they have done in the past.  Basically, your instructions are “I never got yelled at if I stood here so stand here and smile and greet the guests.”  That’s a variation of what their predecessor told them and so on and so forth.  It’s a big game of telephone that gets thrown into a mixer with each new safety officer.  If you aren’t lucky enough to have a handover period with your predecessor (most of the lower class crew do not get any sort of handover - they are thrown to the wolves) you have to ask the people around you in your muster stations where to stand and what to do.  Your answer usually is “I think they stood over there.  I’m not sure, though.  Just say ‘welcome aboard’ and you’re fine.”
Anyone with half a brain can see the problems with this twisted game of telephone.  No one knows exactly what their role is if there is an emergency.  The goal of boat drills is to stand there and not do anything that would make you stand out to the officers who think screaming is the only form of communication.  Be as inconspicuous and friendly to the guests as possible.
So we have inadequate training.  The second part of the disastrous disaster training is that it is more important to get the guests through the drill quickly so they can go back to drinking and being happy than to focus on safety.  Ideally, we should have a passenger list at every muster station and check off each guest as they enter the muster station.  Unfortunately, it takes a lot of time to go through a 50+ page list of passengers when they are all filing in, pissed that they have to leave their drinks outside of the muster station.  You have 5-6 people throwing stateroom numbers at you and you have to rifle through this huge list. 
For example, we have 4 doors in the theater and therefore 4 different lists.  The theater is supposed to hold 1100 people in it.  There is one person at each door with a list.  To make it simple, each person has to check in 275 people (though, of course, it’s spread out differently on each door depending on where people are coming from).  They have to find 275 individual names on a 50+ page list.  At best, that would take 45 minutes.  Then, once it seems like no one else is coming, we have to take the 4 lists and compile them into one.  That takes another 20 minutes.  Then we have to figure out who is missing and announce their names to make sure they weren’t missed.  That would take another 10 minutes.  Then we have to figure out their state rooms and send people to go check if they are there.  We’ll say that takes 30 minutes.
By that time, you have wasted 1 hour and 45 minutes trying to make sure every guest is in the emergency station.  That’s probably under estimating.  For simplicity sake, let’s round it to two hours.  Now, if we were to practice this every cruise (every 4-5 days), we’d get faster and more efficient at it... but the guests’ happiness and open wallets are more important than getting the system to work.  If there was a real emergency, we couldn’t waste two hours getting everyone assembled in the muster station.  That’s clearly evident with the Concordia disaster - in two hours, most of the life boats were inoperable, leaving people stranded on the sinking ship.  
Instead, we take for granted everyone has left the bar or their stateroom and greet them with huge fake smiles as they enter in the muster stations.  When some observant guests ask how we know they are all in the station and accounted for, we are to say that we have “Facial Recognition” cameras.  That’s bull shit.
So we, the crew, have to put all of our faith in the hands of the captain and the senior officers to make sure to keep the emergency drills the pains in the ass they are and not to put us in the situation that we have to refer back to our training on our hectic first day aboard the ship.  I think that is why at least I, personally, have pushed the possibility of a disaster out of my mind... because I don’t like to give up control over my own well being.  I don’t want to look at the captain and wonder if he’s had enough sleep that night.  I don’t want to have to wonder if the captain has gotten bored with our monotonous itinerary and want to take a closer look at an island.  I don’t want to make sure the captain is just drinking club soda instead of an alcoholic beverage.  So I push that possibility out of my mind and not pay attention during drills.  I don’t want to think about the worse case scenario because I know I wouldn’t be able to control anything if the worse case scenario happened.
So, in watching the news and hearing the survivors criticize the crew members, I get a little angry... not at the survivors because they don’t know how things work but at the corporation that is placing all of the blame on the captain and the crew alike.  Yes, it was the captain’s fault... but it is also the cruise line’s fault for not taking safety seriously and training their crew sufficiently.  Guest satisfaction is important, yes, but safety training is just as important, if not more important.  Crew members, by simple mathematics, are more likely to die on a cruise ship than the passengers because they spend the most time on cruise ships.  Therefore we need to have the most information we can to not only save ourselves but to also have the wherewithal to help the passengers.  That’s only fair.  Contrary to what the captains of the world may think, they are NOT the “masters of the vessel.”  They cannot just run dictatorships where crew are treated like numbers and given arbitrary instructions for something as important as safety.  Each crew member is a person, not a number, not a person in an orange vest strategically placed so guests feel as though we know what we are doing, and deserve the right to know how to increase their chances of survival.  We need to know how to take back control over our lives.

3 comments:

  1. Julie says: I hear you, Sara, and beleive me when our cruise comes around March 4th (on Carnival), I personally will remember every word you have just posted and try to follow all your recommendations. It's our 13th and I promise not to get lax like I know I have been. Love to you and thanx

    ReplyDelete
  2. MOM: why not put a name pass in evryones room or hand it to them as they board and they turn it in when the drill is on. then you can figure out who did not make it to the drill. Not sure what kind of penalty can be instilled but at least you have some idea who came. I agree it is hard to teach what to do in an emergency but the muster drills are important and need to be stressed as such. Perhaps this tragedy will indeed wake some people up. Me? I hope it causes the cruise ships to lower their prices (hehehe) so I can come on again to see you!!!! WAHOOOOOO

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kim: I'm with ya Sara! I just heard on the news tonight, the same thing about how it's not just the captain's fault, but corporate and lack of training too. Maybe they read your BLOG!!!!

    ReplyDelete